Democracy Wins in Maldives: Challenges Ahead

70905-Untitled design (5)

 

At last after a A hectic campaigning for elections in Maldives on 23 September 2018, the Election Commission of Maldives declared opposition candidate Ibrahim Mohamed Solih of the Maldivian Democratic Party as the winner of the presidential election. With past record of President Yameen’s autocratic use of power to crush any opposition in the recent past, the contest between him and the opposition candidate Ibrahim Mohamed Solih (Ibu), it was anticipated that the elections may/may not be fair and may well be marred with large scale election rigging/fraud in case President Yameen feels that he may well land up on the losing side. Now everyone is looking at smooth and peaceful transition of power, which would be a good news for democracy of Maldives and positive development for India. 

Is the Situation so Simple

Everyone in the world is looking for smooth transition of Power to the President designate Solih. With past record of President Yameen, and the fact that he will still be in the chair for over month, there is still a doubt lurking in minds of some people of Maldives that he may  resort to declaring emergency, squashing the elections or initiate a coup or civil unrest. The stakes this time may be too high for him, considering the global mood, and India will still have to be ready with its options. In case the transition is smooth, the new President will have to deal with a situation where the finances are a challenge, country is fully under debt trap of China, which also provides maximum revenue through tourism. A resetting of Maldives relations between India and China may take some time, but it is still a good news for India, which was visualising many  strategic and security problems under President Yameen

Maldives continues to be a matter of Security interest to India, due to proximity of the archipelago to its western coast and Indian strategic stakes there. The Chinese desire of land grab (Through debt trap diplomacy), support to dictatorial democracy under Yameen, and the other possibilities of radicalisation in the Maldives archipelago are also a lookout signal for world community, as a sizeable trade from Gulf to Pacific through Indian Ocean passes through eight degree channel between Maldives and India.

The diplomatic tug of war in Maldives seems to be going in favor of China as it seems to have gained a stronghold on President Yameen through “Debt Trap Diplomacy”, with inauguration of China funded Sinamale Bridge, which India chose to boycott. It is a flagship Chinese infrastructure project linking capital Male with the airport island, also referred as China-Maldives Friendship Bridge, with a heavy loan of $72 million besides $116 million grant by Chinese. President Yameen hopes that the optics of this project will perhaps get him some relief from down sliding domestic popularity for the next elections scheduled later this month, after dictatorial acts of targeting Supreme Court Judges and political opponents, unwanted emergency, and bulldozing Free Trade Agreement (FTA) with China, without a debate in Majlis.

Junking ‘India First Policy’: Current crisis with India    

President Yameen seems to have unofficially junked the ‘India First Policy’, when it clearly asked India to remove its second gifted naval chopper (ALH Dhruv) from the Lammu atoll, on expiry of Letter of Exchange (LoE). Lammu being a wide atoll has a potential to be developed into a military base. It is widely believed that Chinese want to build an ocean observatory there, which could be a part of ‘Incremental Encroachment Strategy’, (which could later develop it into military base as it happened in South China Sea) together with ‘Debt Trap’ for a land grab, in case Maldives is unable to pay back the debt, as it has happened in many other countries. The other helicopter located at Addu atoll is also significant being the southernmost island.

Why Maldives can’t be ignored by India?

Maldives archipelago is strategically located in the Arabian Sea very close to Island of Minicoy (Part of India) with Eight Degree Channel separating the two countries. The shipping from the Gulf of Aden and the Gulf of Oman passes through Minicoy and Maldives before sailing eastwards towards Sri-Lanka/ Malacca Straits/ the Java Sea/ Lombok Strait. Similarly the shipping from the North Pacific Ocean, coming westward on its way to Gulf through these areas also passes through this channel, if it wants to avoid longer route circumventing Maldives archipelago. It is estimated that nearly half of the world’s shipping, including crucial oil for Japan and China passes through these choke points, hence control of these choke points is a major strategic concern. Its proximity to India with growing influence of China is another cause of concern, as it is learnt that China has plans to make a Joint Observation Station in Mukunudhu, together with a submarine base. Besides sham democracy under President Yameen, its new found love with Pakistan with their Army Chief visiting Maldives, and potential for radicalization is also an Indian concern.

 

 

What are Indian Options?

India, as a responsible nation recognizes that Maldives is a sovereign country with its right to choose its Government as well as its strategic partners. Any military intervention by India is not a viable option, unlike 1988, when India was invited by the elected President to intervene. India also cannot be a silent spectator to decline of democracy and disorder in immediate neighborhood, hence enhanced naval surface and sub- surface dominance, maritime patrolling in international water, and surveillance by all means needs to be resorted to, which I am sure is being done within international norms.

As per media reports the two Indian naval helicopters, gifted to Maldives, are going to stay along with 48 member crew, is a positive diplomatic step. India needs to negotiate that status quo is maintained in the two atolls where these are located, at least till the elections are over. India could give them the Dornier aircraft as requested by them, as an excuse not to renew LoE later. Further negotiations can be done with the newly elected government.

India needs to generate the international opinion to prevent the anarchy and disorder in Maldives, along with other users of Indian Ocean. International pressure needs to be generated on President Yameen for conducting free and fair elections by ‘Smart Diplomacy’. President Yameen seems to be the preferred candidate to do business for China. He has supported the Chinese Belt and Road Initiative. He will not mind taking Chinese help in whatever form possible for his regime survival. It is highly debatable that a future military base of China in Maldives will be a strength or vulnerability for them in light of distance involved from mainland, inadequate air cover, and high relative strength of Indian Navy and its strategic partners.

On economic front, India can think of economic sanctions if President Yameen continues to pursue anti India stance and manages to come back to power by fair/rigged elections. This however is a double edged weapon, because it can be counter-productive, pushing Maldives in Chinese orbit further. A travel advisory and restriction on tourism can give a decisive blow to their economy, because Maldives’ tourism industry is largest income generating industry, highly dependent on India. In case Maldives inclination is positive, India should continue with goodwill investments like building a Police Academy and other developmental projects.

India also needs to build up its own military capability not only in context of Maldives but other maritime commitments and threats. We need to have more resources to counter threats by PLA Navy submarines in our area of our maritime interest. We need to have good relations with Oman, and getting access to Port of Dukm in Oman, Agreements with France for access to their bases are positive steps in that direction. Periodic inter-operability exercises like Malabar Exercise will continue to send right messages regarding protection of Indian interest in Indian Ocean Region.

Major General S B Asthana, SM,VSM, Chief Instructor, USI of India

(The views expressed are personal views of the author, and do not represent views of any organisation. Major General S B Asthana can be reached as Shashi Asthana on Facebook, LinkedIn, Youtube and Google+, asthana_shashi on Twitter. website http://www.asthanawrites.org)

 

The older versions of similar articles by the author have been published in various newspapers and journals. URLs are given below:-

http://www.futuredirections.org.au/publication/indias-options-in-the-maldives/

http://www.indiandefencereview.com/news/opinion-if-maldives-cant-be-strategically-ignored-what-are-the-options-for-india/

http://www.wionews.com/india-news/opinion-maldives-crisis—options-for-india-163715

http://www.mydigitalfc.com/editorial/india%E2%80%99s-option-vs-maldives

https://asthanawrites.org/2018/09/15/maldives-crisis-options-for-india-my-opinion-on-wion-news/

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s